I've been there many times. The aroma as you walk thru the door will make your mouth water. Owner and staff say hello to everyone and take time to talk with you. The food has never failed to be absolutely delicious. Great place, great atmosphere.
Hands down one of the best restaurants ever! This is AUTHENTIC homemade food made the right way. We have dined here almost 50 times and everything is amazing. Expect a busy chaos- its what gives the Reservoir its "Mom's Kitchen" charm.
This is the best pizza in the area. They have been doing this for 30+ years, using trusted suppliers and time tested quality ingredients, and even more so, time tested methods. I believe it is still family owned and managed. They also have traditional in house dining; for instance last Friday I was picking up two pizzas and saw the daily special "Pan seared sea scallops over sautéed spinach", I almost stayed just for that.
This place is good! Reasonable prices, considerable portions and the staff members are always super friendly.
Some of the best and most underrated pizza and food you can get! I recommend the Tony’s Salad, a pizza, and Chicken Murphy (Don’t get hot peppers if you don’t like heat). The side potatoes are great too. Actually, everything is great here.
List your local Maplewood or South Orange business here!